April 18, 2003

In Milart we read this book called Hitler's Panzers East. The basic argument of the book is that if Hitler hadn't made "one fateful decision" in the summer of '41, Germany could have won the war. After reading the book the first question the class asked was, "is this guy American?" As it turns out the author is American. In the following lessons we had to present on various topics discussed in the book, each person had to vocally point out that they disagreed with Stolfi's argument and that the Germans had no clue what they were getting into in attacking the Soviet Union. I find it interesting that it is almost un-American to say that there are other armies and counties that are better than the US in some aspects. In my Armed Forces and Society class an interesting comment was made in response to my teacher's question of whether or not we thought the US Army would follow the example of other countries in terms of acceptance of homosexuals, conscientious objection, and other post-modern topics. A cadet answered that the US would not follow in other countries' footsteps because as the world power, we are the paradigm and our methods are right. While the reality of the statement is probably sound, I find it a little distressing.

Today we had a lecture by a Holocaust survivor/researcher. His research is centered around understanding what factors allowed for the Holocaust, today he primarily talked to us about his interviews with military SS officers. He posed to us the question, "were the SS murderers, cowards, or warriors?" He then relayed to us the experience he had with his first interview, a man who was an SS four star general. How the man was civil and generous, though authoritarian in nature. He found that the SS men believed they were simply doing their duty to their country.

There was a point I was trying to get to. One of them was the importance of being willing acknowledge the experiences of other people, organizations, and nations. When everything is boiled down, we're all humans, there are a couple outliers that are legitimately insane, but overall there isn't an evil undead race that wants only death and destruction. People/organizations need to learn to see the good things we share, the bad things we share, and the things that might just put others one up. Not that people/organizations don't already do it to a degree, it's just something that can always be worked on.

Journal | Archive | Links | Contact